New Jersey · The Jersey Shore

Pure second-home, on a barrier island.

Stone Harbor and Avalon on Seven Mile Beach, Bay Head and Mantoloking on the northern barrier: these are the Jersey Shore's marquee second-home addresses, and the hardest coastal files in the state. Oceanfront and bayfront values run past what the federal flood program will write, the wind deductible is its own line item, and the houses sit empty for much of the year.

The exposure

Flood goes private, wind has its own deductible, and the rules are rising.

A barrier-island home stacks the coastal problems all at once. Flood first: the National Flood Insurance Program caps residential building coverage at $250,000, and an oceanfront or bayfront house here is worth many multiples of that, so flood goes private and excess, layered above or in place of an NFIP base, sized to the real dwelling value. Wind second: coastal policies carry a separate named-storm or hurricane deductible set as a percentage of the dwelling, and whether a carrier writes it at all turns on elevation, construction, and distance to the water. Occupancy third: these are second homes, empty for long stretches, which changes how water-leak, freeze, and theft are underwritten.

And the bar is moving. New Jersey has been raising its flood-elevation standards (increasing how high at-risk homes must sit when they are built or substantially rebuilt), which changes both what a compliant rebuild costs and how carriers price the risk. Placing a shore home well now means a high-value homeowners form, a private or excess flood layer read against the elevation certificate, a clear-eyed named-storm deductible, and second-home occupancy terms that will not void a winter water loss. Almost every one of these files belongs with the specialty and high-net-worth insurers, and the excess-and-surplus flood and wind markets.

The pockets

Where the value concentrates.

The figures below are U.S. Census ACS 5-Year estimates for each place: household income, home value, the share of households over $200k, and the seasonal share of vacant homes. They frame the file; they do not set the rate.

Stone Harbor

Seven Mile Beach, Cape May County: a premier family second-home market of oceanfront and back-bay homes, overwhelmingly seasonal.

Median income

$169,167

ACS B19013, 2024

Median home value

$2.0M+

owner-occupied · ACS B25077, 2024 · top-coded ceiling

Households >$200k

45.7%

ACS B19001, 2024

Seasonal of vacant

94.4%

share of vacant homes · ACS B25004, 2024

Avalon

The northern half of Seven Mile Beach: high-value beach-block and bayfront homes, almost entirely second homes.

Median income

$139,167

ACS B19013, 2024

Median home value

$1,959,000

owner-occupied · ACS B25077, 2024

Households >$200k

28.9%

ACS B19001, 2024

Seasonal of vacant

94.9%

share of vacant homes · ACS B25004, 2024

Mantoloking

An ultra-exclusive northern barrier-island borough: oceanfront and bayfront homes rebuilt after Sandy, among the highest-value shore addresses in the state.

Median income

$250K+

ACS B19013, 2024 · top-coded ceiling

Median home value

$2.0M+

owner-occupied · ACS B25077, 2024 · top-coded ceiling

Households >$200k

64.1%

ACS B19001, 2024

Seasonal of vacant

94.5%

share of vacant homes · ACS B25004, 2024

Bay Head

A small, historic barrier-island borough at the top of the Ocean County shore: oceanfront second homes with full coastal exposure.

Median income

$181,667

ACS B19013, 2024

Median home value

$1,864,000

owner-occupied · ACS B25077, 2024

Households >$200k

47.3%

ACS B19001, 2024

Seasonal of vacant

88.2%

share of vacant homes · ACS B25004, 2024

Why an independent agency

This is specialty-carrier territory.

Oceanfront value, named-storm wind, and seasonal occupancy take a shore home out of the standard market and into the specialty and high-net-worth insurers, and the excess-and-surplus flood and wind markets. Armor Group assembles the layers (homeowners, private flood, wind) as one placement, and stays the same point of contact year over year.

Written by

Armor Group Insurance Agency
New York licensed independent insurance agency
Questions

What The Jersey Shore households ask.

Data sources for this page

Demographic data: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates (2024). Tables: B19013 (median household income), B25077 (median value of owner-occupied units), B19001 (households $200,000+), B25004 (seasonal/recreational vacant units). ACS top-codes median income at $250,001 and median home value at $2,000,001; figures at those ceilings are shown as “$250K+” / “$2.0M+”.

Insurance information on this page is general and does not bind coverage. Coverage availability and terms vary; contact us for your specific situation.

Begin

Tell us about the shore house.

If your household keeps a second home in Stone Harbor, Avalon, Mantoloking, Bay Head, or along the Jersey Shore, tell us what you are protecting. You'll work with a dedicated agent on the coast, and the principal reviews every file.